Skip to main content

FOOLED BY GOOGLE EARTH

I laid out a preliminary 5k course on Saturday morning. I used a fire hydrant as a reference for the finish line. The hydrant was at the extreme northwest corner of Columbus Commons. The Commons is a new park in downtown Columbus, replacing several old buildings that were torn down and replaced with grass.

When I was done the course was a bit short, and I found that I needed to add 600 feet. Using a measuring wheel I measured south from the hydrant and established a provisional finish line. I measured twice, obtaining 600 and 601 feet, thus had confidence in my measurement.

Later I used Google Earth to check out the 600 feet. To my surprise the Google distance came out to just a bit over 300 feet. This was vexing, and I fiddled with various comparisons to see if I could figure out where the error was. I was greatly concerned because I have become a believer in the accuracy of Google Earth.

After several frustrating and ineffective tries to find the error I was stumped. Then I did a search for “Columbus Commons” and obtained a map of the site. I discovered that the Lazarus building was no longer there. It had been torn down and the area replaced by grass. Thus my reference was at the wrong place – it was actually at the northwest corner of the Lazarus Building in the Google image. Sure enough, the date of the Google image was 2/28/2007. It was photographed before the Lazarus building was torn down.

Using the northwest corner of the former Lazarus Building as my reference, I now got close to 600 feet. This was an instructive lesson. The Google Earth image we see is not actually up to date.

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

More troubling, Pete, is that the Lazarus building is gone. I used to go down there and look at the Christmas window displays, back when I was a kid (in the 60s). Another icon of childhood memories, gone.

You are right about the photos - we need to make sure they accurately represent what is there, as the images may be very old. Also, I looked at downtown Houston tonight, and the photo was not taken from directly above the downtown area. You cannot see the streets in the area, as the buildings shield all the streets. The satellite image is worthless for pre-measuring a course through downtown Houston.
A footnote about using different dates of Google images, I'm sure many know this but some may not have thought of it: A lot of times the displayed images are taken in warm weather, with plenty of tree cover hiding the roads or trails, so I've often had better luck when I go back in time and pick an image taken in the winter. Doesn't help with conifers-- or buildings in Columbus or Houston. (There's a height limit in DC which improves your chances of seeing all the streets.)

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×